Avoiding Expensive Mistakes: Implementation That Sticks

As with any major initiative, disciplined planning prevents issues that can turn a promising project into an expensive dilemma — and erode confidence that your organizationcan manage change. Implementation is a structured business transformation that brings operations, data, and people into alignment so you can realize the measurable outcomes you expect.

Implementation isn’t just the vendor’s job; your internal team and software partners must act like true partners. It requires clear ownership, thoughtful sequencing, active communication, and the discipline to address issues before they escalate. Most important, software may promise efficiency; only a carefully managed implementation delivers it.

The first two articles in this series covered how to pick the right system1 and negotiate a fair, protective contract.2 This article will help you turn selection and contracting into results by managing implementation with clear ownership, realistic timelines, and evidence-based go-live criteria.

The Five Swim Lanes

Many teams assume the hard work ends at signature. But in reality, that’s when the hard work begins.

Implementation is not simply toggling settings, handing out logins, and flipping a switch — it’s a multiphase project within the project that must be led deliberately to avoid costly rework. Manage implementation through five swim lanes:

1. Application Configuration

Application configuration is when the vendor’s standard system is molded to fit how your company works, including workflows, permissions, cost codes, approval hierarchies, and financial controls.

Aim for efficient workflows rather than replicas of the past. Many companies mirror legacy steps without questioning if those steps still make sense. It’s important to do process optimization before configuration and then configure to the new process.

2. Data Migration

Data migration moves years of business, project, vendor, customer, and financial information into the new system.

Legacy data is often messy: duplicates, inconsistent names, outdated cost codes, and conflicting spreadsheets. It’s important to not “lift and shift” — without cleanup and validation, poor data undermines trust from day one and drives emergency fixes. Treat migration like its own project with profiling, deduplication, standards, and reconciliation checkpoints.

3. Systems Integration

Your new software cannot operate on an island. For enterprise resource planning (ERP), that may include payroll, HR, project management, estimating, and document control.

Well-planned integrations reduce duplicate entry and keep departments aligned with near-real-time data. Design for error handling, retry logic, monitoring, and audit trails — not just data movement.

4. User Acceptance Testing

User acceptance testing is the final defense against costly surprises after go-live. Employees must run daily tasks using real data, ensuring they cover end-to-end workflows, exception paths, what-ifs, and record pass/fail evidence.

If you shortcut user acceptance testing, then you’ll discover defects after you’ve turned off the old system.

5. Training

Even the best-configured system fails if people don’t know how and why to use it. Deliver role-based, scenario-driven training with quick-reference guides, recordings, office hours, and on-demand refreshers. Plan a 30/60/90-day reinforcement cadence and include new-hire onboarding.

If you are a CFMA member login to continue reading this article. If you aren't a member yet and would like unlimited access to all of the content on cfma.org, plus a variety of other benefits, join CFMA today!